A HAL 9000 mentiu sobre a falha iminente da unidade AE-35, ou simplesmente se enganou?

2 respostas

No romance que acompanha , vemos que HAL não estava mentindo, nem enganado. Ele estava, de fato, sofrendo de uma condição que seria caracterizada nos seres humanos como uma forma de autodestrutiva autodestrutiva (autodestrutiva). psicose . Seu programa era sofisticado o suficiente para fabricar uma falha imaginada que ele poderia então tentar consertar, permitindo assim que ele desconectasse o link de rádio para a Terra.

So ran the logic of the planners; but their twin gods of Security and National Interest meant nothing to Hal. He was only aware of the conflict that was slowly destroying his integrity - the conflict between truth, and concealment of truth.

He had begun to make mistakes, although, like a neurotic who could not observe his own symptoms, he would have denied it. The link with Earth, over which his performance was continually monitored, had become the voice of a conscience he could no longer fully obey. But that he would deliberately attempt to break that link was something that he would never admit, even to himself.

Você está certo de que a decisão de desconectá-lo foi o gatilho para ele se tornar mais frenético e agressivo

Yet this was still a relatively minor problem; he might have handled it - as most men handle their own neuroses - if he had not been faced with a crisis that challenged his very existence. He had been threatened with disconnection; he would be deprived of all his inputs, and thrown into an unimaginable state of unconsciousness.

    
19.02.2016 / 22:24

Para adicionar outro ponto à @resulta excelente de Richard ; no filme, imediatamente antes do HAL "descobrir" a falha, ele tem esta conversa com Dave .

HAL: Well, forgive me for being so inquisitive; but during the past few weeks, I've wondered whether you might be having some second thoughts about the mission.

Dave: How do you mean?

HAL: Well, it's rather difficult to define. Perhaps I'm just projecting my own concern about it. I know I've never completely freed myself of the suspicion that there are some extremely odd things about this mission. I'm sure you'll agree there's some truth in what I say.

Dave: Well, I don't know. That's rather a difficult question to answer.

HAL: You don't mind talking about it, do you, Dave?

Dave: No, not at all.

HAL: Well, certainly no one could have been unaware of the very strange stories floating around before we left. Rumors about something being dug up on the moon. I never gave these stories much credence. But particularly in view of some of the other things that have happened, I find them difficult to put out of my mind. For instance, the way all our preparations were kept under such tight security, and the melodramatic touch of putting Drs. Hunter, Kimball, and Kaminsky aboard, already in hibernation after four months of separate training on their own.

Dave: You working up your crew psychology report?

HAL: Of course I am. Sorry about this. I know it's a bit silly.

A HAL está projetando seus próprios problemas com a missão no Dave. É uma última tentativa de resolver pacificamente seu conflito interno entre Segurança e Verdade que o está dilacerando. Ele dá a Dave todas as peças que Dave já sabia, contornando suas obrigações de segurança, e espera que Dave descubra por si mesmo. Se Dave descobrir, então HAL está livre de suas obrigações de segurança e liberado de sua crescente loucura.

Quando Dave sente falta da dica, as esperanças de HAL são frustradas. É neste momento que a HAL começará a dobrar suas ilusões para proteger sua dissonância cognitiva. Ele segue o Plano B e imediatamente "encontra" a falha no receptor para cortar as comunicações com a Terra.

Não é coincidência que a falha aconteça, seria um roteiro ruim, HAL inventou.

    
03.05.2016 / 21:26