Na verdade, ela deveria ter uma conversa com Damon e Stefan (longe da festa, mas não do lado de fora da sala de festas). A coisa é que Jeremy viu Elena indo embora com os dois vampiros, e a seguiu porque ele se preocupava com ela se metendo em alguns planos perigosos, e também porque ele não queria que ela ficasse com os dois vampiros.
Durante a conversa, Damon propôs matar Alaric, que é para ele a única solução. Jeremy ouviu e não suportou a ideia de perder Alaric (que é como um pai para ele).
Sentindo-se chateado, Jeremy se afastou de Elena e dos dois vampiros. Elena viu o quanto ele estava chateado e queria confortá-lo.
Então, ela tentou impedi-lo de ir embora, e foi assim que Jeremy levou sua irmã para fora da festa ...
Lá, depois de algumas conversas entre irmãs e irmãos, eles conheceram Esther que "forçou" Elena a acompanhá-la (caso contrário, ela faria mal aos que ela ama ...)
Elena decidiu segui-la para evitar ferir alguém.
Script:
Damon: We three need to talk. (speaking to Elena and Stefan)
(Jeremy sees Elena and the 2 vamps leaving the party)
Jeremy: Sorry. Uh (bumping into his ex-girlfriend Bonnie and his new boyfriend Jamie)
Hey. Bonnie.
Bonnie: Why are you still wearing your ring? Didn't Elena tell you?
Jeremy: Yeah, yeah, I know all about Alaric. My sister stops hanging out with vampires, I'll take it off.
(Jeremy goes away)
Jamie: Uh, ex-boyfriend?
Bonnie: Yep.
Jamie: That's not awkward at all.
(Away from the party)
Elena: If Alaric's sick, then we need to find a cure, something.
Damon: We tried medicine. We tried magic.
Stefan: Why don't we get him off vervain, compel him?
Damon: To do what, pretend to be Alaric? The guy that we know is gone.
We're talking about someone who not only hates vampires, but vampire sympathizers, which makes one of his most obvious targets I don't know you, you?
Stefan: What? You think he'd go after Elena?
Elena: So wait. What are you suggesting we do?
Damon: I'm suggesting that we put him out of his misery.
Elena: What?
(Jeremy is behind Elena and heard Damon's last conversation)
Jeremy: No way in hell.
Damon: Oh, come on. It's what he would want. It's a mercy killing.
Jeremy: You are out of your mind.
Elena: Jeremy
(Jeremy goes away, feeling very upset - Elena goes after her brother and they're both outside the party room)
Elena: Jer, stop.
Jeremy: This is Alaric we're talking about. You know, he looked out for us, and we need to do the same for him.
Elena: No one's gonna hurt him.
(Jeremy tries to go away)
Elena: Hey. Hey. Look at me. I promise.
Esther: Elena.
(Elena looks behind her)
Esther: If you wish to help your friend Alaric, I suggest you come with me.
Elena: Jeremy, go inside and get Stefan and Damon now.
Esther: I mean you no harm, but willingly or not, you will come.