Um feitiço de desintegração destruirá instantaneamente uma arma espiritual?

Question

Um feitiço de desintegração destruirá instantaneamente uma arma espiritual?

Navegue suas respostas

#1 resposta do (8 votos)
#2 resposta do (3 votos)

25

O desintegrar estados de feitiço:

This spell automatically disintegrates a Large or smaller nonmagical object or a creation of magical force.

Feitiços como Mão de Bigby e Espada de Mordenkainen Estado:

You create a Large hand of shimmering, translucent force in an unoccupied space that you can see within range.

e

You create a sword-shaped plane of force that hovers within range.

This wording suggests that desintegrar can instantly destroy either of these spells, since they are explicitly creations of magical force. But arma espiritual afirma:

You create a floating, spectral weapon within range...

The weapon deals force damage, and is almost identical to Espada de Mordenkainen, but is it a creation of magical force that desintegrar can instantly destroy?

dnd-5e feitiços

por Adão 29.06.2019 / 16:17

2 respostas

Spiritual Weapon seems to be Force

It parece to be a force effect since the entry for Arma Espiritual on D&D Beyond says "Damage/Effect: Force". From historical canon: Spiritual Weapon in previous editions has explicitly been "a weapon made of pure force", and I don't see an intent by the 5e writers to have this changed (else the wording wouldn't still make it seem made of force).

I'll admit RAW is open to interpretation, but when making a ruling at the table: Intuitively, disallowing disintegrate from working on Spiritual Weapon seems likely to brook an argument from players, while allowing it seems unlikely to (even if you use it against them).

30.06.2019 / 21:13

Tags dnd-5e feitiços

Que diferenças de aeronave ou companhia aérea tornariam o Sukhoi Superjet inadequado para as operações aéreas regionais dos EUA? Substituídos os tubos fluorescentes por tubos de LED, os LEDs só acendem quando tocados

score 8 · Accepted Answer

Desintegrar won't destroy arma espiritual

Feitiços fazem o que eles dizem que fazeme arma espiritual doesn't say it creates an object of magical force. By a strict interpretation, desintegrar won't destroy arma espiritual.

You can house-rule otherwise by duck testing.

If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.

As your examples point out, arma espiritual behaves much like examples of magical force created by similar spells. This is a decent argument for "spectral" being equivalent to "magical force". However, that determination is up to each table.