Que versão do Hobbit e do LOTR devo comprar? [fechadas]

3

Estou inclinado a ler o Hobbit e o LOTR, mas há muitas versões dele quando olho para a Amazon, por exemplo. A "versão" está em termos de:

  • revisões
  • ilustrações (eu gostaria da de Tolkien)
  • Correções de erros
  • conjunto de caixas / não
  • ano publicado

Qual deles devo comprar? Eu apreciarei se você fornecer o ISBN e o motivo da sua resposta.

    
por hans-t 20.06.2014 / 05:50

2 respostas

A primeira impressão em capa dura, é claro, mas você precisará retirar seu talão de cheques. Se não essa edição, qualquer edição dos anos 60 contará a mesma história básica. Você não precisa se limitar a uma edição também. Você pode obter várias edições para a arte diferente, se nada mais. Nenhuma edição de revisão 'moderna' alterará visivelmente a história e apenas um especialista em hardcore notará qualquer diferença.

Veja o que o Wiki diz sobre as diferentes revisões:

Revisions[edit]

In December 1937, The Hobbit's publisher, Stanley Unwin, asked Tolkien for a sequel. In response Tolkien provided drafts for The Silmarillion, but the editors rejected them, believing that the public wanted "more about hobbits".[48] Tolkien subsequently began work on The New Hobbit, which would eventually become The Lord of the Rings,[48] a course that would not only change the context of the original story, but lead to substantial changes to the character of Gollum.

In the first edition of The Hobbit, Gollum willingly bets his magic ring on the outcome of the riddle-game, and he and Bilbo part amicably.[9] In the second edition edits, to reflect the new concept of the ring and its corrupting abilities, Tolkien made Gollum more aggressive towards Bilbo and distraught at losing the ring. The encounter ends with Gollum's curse, "Thief! Thief, Thief, Baggins! We hates it, we hates it, we hates it forever!" This presages Gollum's portrayal in The Lord of the Rings.

Tolkien sent this revised version of the chapter "Riddles in the Dark" to Unwin as an example of the kinds of changes needed to bring the book into conformity with The Lord of the Rings, but he heard nothing back for years. When he was sent galley proofs of a new edition, Tolkien was surprised to find the sample text had been incorporated.[49] In The Lord of the Rings, the original version of the riddle game is explained as a "lie" made up by Bilbo under the harmful influence of the Ring, whereas the revised version contains the "true" account.[50] The revised text became the second edition, published in 1951 in both the UK and the US.[51]

Tolkien began a new version in 1960, attempting to adjust the tone of The Hobbit to its sequel. He abandoned the new revision at chapter three after he received criticism that it "just wasn't The Hobbit", implying it had lost much of its light-hearted tone and quick pace.[52]

After an unauthorized paperback edition of The Lord of the Rings appeared from Ace Books in 1965, Houghton Mifflin and Ballantine asked Tolkien to refresh the text of The Hobbit to renew the US copyright.[53] This text became the 1966 third edition. Tolkien took the opportunity to align the narrative even more closely to The Lord of the Rings and to cosmological developments from his still unpublished Quenta Silmarillion as it stood at that time.[54] These small edits included, for example, changing the phrase "elves that are now called Gnomes" from the first[55] and second[56] editions on page 63, to "High Elves of the West, my kin" in the third edition.[57] Tolkien had used "gnome" in his earlier writing to refer to the second kindred of the High Elves—the Noldor (or "Deep Elves")—thinking "gnome", derived from the Greek gnosis (knowledge), was a good name for the wisest of the elves. However, because of its common denotation of a garden gnome, derived from the 16th-century Paracelsus, Tolkien abandoned the term.[58]

Como eu aponto, para obter edições antecipadas você pagará generosamente ... se você pudesse encontrar uma. Pegando uma impressão de 70 ou mais tarde vai impedi-lo de jeito nenhum.

    
20.06.2014 / 06:14

Embora a história seja a mesma em todas as edições atuais, a menos que seja uma recontagem ( tremor ), Tolkien também ilustrou os livros.

Uma edição que apresenta essas ilustrações é, IMHO, preferível.

    
20.06.2014 / 07:30