Definitivamente faça isso pelo momento da história.
(Abaixo, adicionamos uma seção descrevendo como isso acabou tocando ao vivo).
Eis por que decidimos permitir que essa situação acontecesse:
It is the final moment where PCs reach the very bottom level of the Tomb with all the keys. Suddenly, one of the PCs fails a Hold Person roll. One of the keys is stolen by a hag. The Hag cackles hideously as she turns Ethereal and the PCs watch as what feels like all their hope is lost. It is an epic story moment. According to Joseph Campbell, this moment is often part of the “Hero’s Journey” in myths. As a result, it seems like a terrible shame to prevent players from experiencing such a powerful, potentially mythic, moment of the story. But then how does the story continue?
Veja como decidimos resolver os problemas da história que surgiram:
For our particular game, the PCs had freed the Keshma the Dao. Withers, the tomb warden with all the crawling hands, is still alive. (He is even described as someone who flees rather than fight to the death.) Keshma is listed as knowing details about the Tomb. We decided that when the key is stolen and the PCs stand around stunned and unsure what to do, Keshma can say she knows that the Tomb has a warden who resets the Tomb. She has seen him wander the Tomb. He resets the Skeleton Keys as well. Thus, she can say she knows that the Hags must give the Keys to him to reset the Tomb. She can say she is certain his office is on the same level as her because she was carried in the bottle through it at one time but isn’t certain where exactly on that level. Withers will have the key in his office.
Além disso, no que diz respeito aos seus adversários ...
By allowing the key to be stolen, it means that the Hags can work their hardest to actually try to do what they would try to do if the situation were real and they worked for Acerak trying to raise a new God. (i.e. They would practically give their lives to steal a single key from the PCs to prevent them from getting to the Atropol.)
O resultado é que esta solução está ligada ao ciclo de vida real do Túmulo. Dá aos jogadores mais histórias para descobrir. Dá-lhes mais do túmulo para experimentar e, talvez mais importante, preserva um momento de história potencial da "Jornada do Herói".
Como um adendo, hoje eu corri o jogo onde usamos este final.
Aqui está como tudo aconteceu e como os jogadores responderam.
The players started putting the keys into the door as they got them. As they finished getting the last key. The Hags all appeared in front of the door. The players then realized the Hags were going to steal them but it was too late. Only one character got an action before the Hags each grabbed a key and went Ethereal. One character went ethereal to chase the Hags but it was too late. The Hags ran off cackling.
Um personagem que não conseguiu pegá-los disse: "é isso. Eles se foram". Ela disse isso com a finalidade. Os jogadores pareciam atordoados. Eles rapidamente pensaram em como recuperar as chaves, mas não conseguiam pensar em nada. Os jogadores pareciam um pouco chocados quando a futilidade afundou.
We didn't make the players suffer too long. We felt like if we waited too long they would truly lose hope and feel disconnected from the game. It felt like I needed to connect the hope really quickly to keep the story moving. At that moment I had the Dao step forward. (A player had released her from the bottle.) The Dao said she knew there was a caretaker, Withers, who was in charge of resetting the dungeon. She said that the hags would eventually have to give the keys to him. The party hid out for several hours waiting until they thought the keys might have been given back to him. Then they stormed his office and killed Withers. We tried to keep this backtracking part quick. Finding the keys they returned to the room where the hags were waiting. The Hags tried again to get the keys but this time the party stayed close to Dragonbait to get advantage on their saves. After killing two of the hags the last bargained for her life. Though it may not have been this incident itself, as we finished the session, one of players said that the session was "awesome" and the others on the discord channel said they agreed. So at least anecdotally - it didn't seem to detract from the adventure - and even perhaps enhanced it.
Houve uma sensação muito leve de diminuição do impulso em torno do retrocesso, então a conclusão é que, ao adotar essa abordagem, você deve manter o retrocesso muito curto se quiser que ele seja bem-sucedido.