“My womb isn’t a tool for you to borrow whenever you like. I love Rhombur. He is my husband, and I will not be a brood mare for you.”
...
“It will not be an extraordinary commitment—three daughters, no more, with different fathers.”
...
“I have other obligations now. I am also a wife and mother, and I will not turn my back on all that. If you can’t understand why, then you’re ill-informed about human nature. I shall accept no other lover than Rhombur. That is not a subject for negotiation.”
A resposta da Irmandade foi enviar o primeiro 'Caçador de Culpa' depois dela:
“You have always had a purpose to serve, but now I have another use for you. The Sisterhood cannot allow open defiance without consequences. Therefore everyone must see your guilt, and you must feel it. You must know it.”
...
“Never forget that you belong to the Sisterhood—heart, mind, soul, and flesh. You exist to serve. Contemplate that in your personal hell.”
Então, ela violou ordens, mas ficou catatônica e obrigada a obedecê-las de qualquer maneira, contra sua vontade.
Provavelmente, acho que Sheena em 'Chaperhouse' também conta, mas isso estava mais perto de um cisma, separando-se da 'nova' Bene Gesserit, do que uma violação direta de ordens.